Simple or Complex Filtration: What's Right for You?
Simple vs. Complex Filtration: What’s Right for Your Saltwater Aquarium?
One of the most important—and often debated—topics in saltwater aquarium keeping is filtration. How much do you really need? Is a protein skimmer mandatory? Should you invest in a UV sterilizer? In this episode of This or That, we’re breaking it all down to help you make the best decision for your tank without spending more than necessary.
What Is "Simple" Filtration?
When we talk about simple filtration for a saltwater tank, we’re typically referring to setups that rely on:
- Live Rock as the primary source of biological filtration
- Mechanical Filtration (like filter socks or sponges)
- Activated Carbon (optional)
This kind of setup is ideal for beginners or anyone setting up a minimalist reef tank. In fact, if you're only planning to keep a few corals and maybe a couple of fish, you can absolutely get away with just live rock and solid water movement. The live rock provides ample surface area for beneficial bacteria, while powerheads help maintain oxygenation and nutrient transport.
The Case for Going Simple
If your primary goal is to grow coral and you’re only keeping a light fish load, simple filtration can be more than enough. A few soft corals, some basic LPS (Large Polyp Stony) corals, and a couple of peaceful fish can thrive in a basic setup.
Why Keep it Simple?
- Cost-Effective: No need to invest in expensive equipment up front.
- Less Equipment Maintenance: Fewer gadgets to clean and troubleshoot.
- Less Electricity Usage: A simpler system often means a smaller power bill.
- Perfect for Small to Mid-Sized Tanks: Ideal for tanks in the below 80 gallons or so.
Of course, this does require you to stay on top of regular water changes and manual maintenance. But for many hobbyists, that trade-off is worth it.
When to Upgrade Your Filtration
As your tank becomes more heavily stocked—especially with fish—the amount of waste increases. More waste means more water pollutants, which means more need for filtration.
At this point, you might consider adding:
- Protein Skimmer: Helps remove organic waste before it breaks down.
- UV Sterilizer: Great for improving water clarity and reducing disease risk.
- Refugium or Algae Reactor: Natural nutrient export with macroalgae like Chaeto.
- Media Reactor: Easily use filter media for targeted nutrient control and/or water clarity.
If you’ve got a tank full of fish and corals, or you’re feeding heavily, these additions can make your life a lot easier and help maintain stability.
Building a High-End Filtration System
As your reef matures or your goals become more ambitious, upgrading to a complex filtration system isn’t just about adding more gear—it’s about unlocking greater stability, flexibility, and control over your aquarium’s ecosystem.
- Controllable protein skimmer
- Automatic filter rollers
- Refugium with macroalgae
- UV sterilizer
- GFO or carbon reactors
- Bio-media blocks for added surface area
- Automated testing and dosing systems
Why go Complex?
- Improved Stability: More gear = more tools to manage nutrient levels, pH, and water clarity with precision. This is especially critical for delicate SPS corals or tanks with high fish loads.
- Less Daily Maintenance: While there’s more equipment to maintain occasionally, you’ll spend less time each day dealing with water changes, algae outbreaks, or chasing parameters.
- Better for Heavily Stocked Tanks: High bioload systems demand extra filtration horsepower to avoid crashes or chronic nutrient issues.
- Room to Grow: A large sump gives you the freedom to add more fish or try new filtration techniques without a full system redesign.
- Automation = Peace of Mind: Whether it’s remote monitoring or automatic nutrient export, complex filtration systems can help safeguard your tank when you’re away.
Yes, a complex system may cost more upfront and require thoughtful planning, but for passionate reefers, the long-term convenience, performance, and protection can be well worth it.
What’s the Right Choice for You?
If you’re just getting started, don’t feel pressured to go all-in on high-end gear. A basic setup with live rock, powerheads, and regular water changes can absolutely be successful, especially if you’re focusing on coral and keeping your fish load light.
And if you're the type of aquarist who enjoys tweaking, upgrading, and building a fully automated reef system, there’s no limit to how complex you can go. Just know that with every upgrade comes added maintenance responsibility.
Filtration isn’t one-size-fits-all. Whether you're keeping it simple or going all-out, the most important thing is understanding the needs of your specific tank and building a system that works for you. Start small, learn what your tank needs, and grow your filtration along with your experience.
Have fun, experiment, and remember: some of the best tanks we’ve seen are the most minimal.
Login and Registration Form